Regulator Questions Delay Dow-DuPont Deal


European regulators have called for a pause in their review of the proposed merger between two chemical giants due to what they're calling missing information, while a U.S. Senate committee prepares to discuss the possible fallout of the deal.

The European Commission had initiated a Phase II review Aug. 11 to determine whether the proposed merger-of-equals between The Dow Chemical Company and DuPont is in line with the EU Merger Regulation.

Just about a month later, the EC announced it was halting its review process because the companies had failed to submit required data, The Wall Street Journal reported.

“The commission has stopped the clock in its in-depth investigation into the proposed merger between Dow and DuPont,” European Commission spokesman Ricardo Cardoso said.

“To comply with merger deadlines, parties must supply the necessary information for the investigation in a timely fashion.”

The Journal noted that extensions during EU merger reviews are not uncommon.

At the same time, the U.S. Senate Judiciary Committtee will be holding a hearing this week that could have an affect on the outcome of the merger plan.

Shifting Timelines

At the time the deal was announced, the companies forecast completion of the transaction by the second half of 2016, if federal antitrust regulatory commissioners approved the deal. (The companies each received the formal approval of their respective shareholders in July to move forward with the planned merger.)

The timeline later shifted to early 2017 when the EC announced a revised review deadline of Jan. 11. Now, with the postponement of the investigation, the review deadline is likely to be pushed back further.

Dow and DuPont

The paints and coatings industry has focused on the side of the deal that will combine the two chemical and coatings titans into “powerful innovation and material science leaders.”

"Once the missing information is supplied by the parties, the clock is restarted and the deadline for the commission's decision is then adjusted accordingly," Cardoso said.

However, a DuPont source told The News Journal that the matter was a “document production issue” that the company could remedy quickly.

Dan Turner, a spokesman for DuPont, referred to the request for information as "a routine procedural part" of the review process, adding, "It does not change our timing expectations."

The nature of the missing information was not disclosed.

Areas of Concern

As reported previously, upon completion of the $130 billion deal, the companies plan to form a new entity, DowDuPont, that would later split into three separate independent, publicly traded companies focused on material science, agriculture and specialty products.

DowDuPont split

The Agriculture segment of the three independent, publicly traded companies that will spin off from the new DowDuPont is causing antitrust concerns, as it “take place in industries that are already globally concentrated,” the European Commission said.

The paints and coatings industry has focused on the side of the deal that will combine the two chemical and coatings titans into “powerful innovation and material science leaders.”

The EC’s concerns, however, lay on the agricultural side of the business, saying the proposed merger would create the world's largest integrated crop protection and seeds company.

“It would also create a leading integrated producer of certain petrochemical products that are widely used in packaging and adhesive applications,” the EC noted. “The transaction would take place in industries that are already globally concentrated.”

Earlier in the year both companies had privately shared proposed concessions to EU authorities to address antitrust concerns, sources said, but the EC responded that the concessions were "insufficient to clearly dismiss its serious doubts."

The agency may ask for additional concessions, according to Margrethe Vestager, head of the EC.

"The livelihood of farmers depends on access to seeds and crop protection at competitive prices," Vestager said. "We need to make sure the proposed merger does not lead to higher prices or less innovation for these products."

U.S. Senate Testimony

The merger is currently undergoing related reviews in the U.S., Canada and Brazil.

In the U.S., the Senate Judiciary Committee will discuss this week how the proposed merger might affect American farmers. The hearing, set to take place today (Sept. 20), will reportedly feature testimony from executives from Dow and DuPont, as well as from Bayer AG and Monsanto Company, two other major players in the agriculture industry that announced a merger plan of their own last week.


Tagged categories: Asia Pacific; Business matters; Coatings Technology; Dow Chemical Company; DuPont; EMEA (Europe, Middle East and Africa); Industry News; Latin America; Mergers; North America

Join the Conversation:

Sign in to our community to add your comments.