Coatings Industry News

Main News Page

Solvents Tied to Later Brain Problems

Wednesday, May 14, 2014

Comment | More

Time supposedly heals all wounds, but it may not be able to repair the brain problems caused by longtime on-the-job exposure to industrial coatings and other solvent-based products, a new study shows.

Sustained, high-level exposure to vapors from industrial paints and coatings, adhesives and other solvent-based products may compromise brain function in workers decades after they have left the job, according to research conducted by a team at the Harvard School of Public Health.

'Harmful Effects'

“This study adds to the mounting evidence not only of the harmful effects of solvent exposure on cognitive function in the short term, but also of the health effects that may last long past the time of exposure," Dr. Erika L. Sabbath, the study leader, told PaintSquare News by email Tuesday (May 13).

U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics

The study looked at retirees, rather than active workers, who are presumably healthier if they are still on the job. More than 2,100 retirees participated.

In a study of retired French utility workers, Sabbath found significant association between memory and thinking impairment and longtime occupational exposure to chlorinated solvents, benzene or petroleum solvents.

Some of the retirees showed problems 30 to 50 years after their exposure—a finding that Sabbath called "really surprising."

“[Other] studies haven’t shown effects that persist this long,” Sabbath told Time Magazine.

Longer Careers, More Exposure

The findings have major implications for exposure limit policies for industrial painters, construction workers and others who have high, ongoing exposure to solvent-based products, says Sabbath.

The potential for damage is particularly high for today's workers, who stay on the job longer and longer, Sabbath noted.

Her study, "Time may not fully attenuate solvent-associated cognitive deficits in highly exposed workers," has just been published in Neurology, the journal of the American Academy of Neurology.

© iStock / shime02

"Solvents pose a real risk to the present and future cognitive health of workers," says the study's director.

"Solvents pose a real risk to the present and future cognitive health of workers, and as retirement ages go up, the length of time that people are exposed is going up, too," said Sabbath.

Utility Workers Studied

The research examined memory, attention and processing speed in 2,143 retirees who had been potentially exposed to three types of solvents in their careers:

  • 33 percent had been exposed to chlorinated solvents;
  • 26 percent had been exposed to benzene; and
  • 25 percent had been exposed to petroleum solvents.

All three solvents are widely used in various products throughout the paint and coatings industry.

The workers' average lifetime exposure was ranked as none, moderate or high, based on company records, the nature of their jobs, and on when their last exposure occurred.

Participants took eight tests of their memory and thinking skills an average of 10 years after they retired, when they were an average age of 66. (Ninety percent of workers retired between ages 50 and 60.)

Researchers also accounted for factors such as education level, age, smoking and alcohol consumption. They did not control for factors such as cardiovascular disease, diet or physical activity and concede that these may play a role in cognitive functioning.

Impairment in Majority

A total of 59 percent of the participants showed impairment on one to three of the eight tests; 23 percent had impairment on four or more tests; 18 percent had no impaired scores.

U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics

The risk from occupational exposure to solvents is expected to increase as workers stay on the job longer.

People with high, recent exposure to solvents were found to be at greatest risk for memory and thinking deficits.

For example, those with high, recent exposure to chlorinated solvents were 65 percent more likely to have impaired scores on tests of memory and visual attention and task switching than those who were not exposed, according to an AAN research announcement.

“The people with high exposure within the last 12 to 30 years showed impairment in almost all areas of memory and thinking, including those not usually associated with solvent exposure,” Sabbath said.

“But what was really striking was that we also saw some cognitive problems in those who had been highly exposed much longer ago, up to 50 years before testing.

"This suggests that time may not fully lessen the effect of solvent exposure on some memory and cognitive skills when lifetime exposure is high.”

Reaching Workers

The study says it is one of the first to study such exposures by examining retirees. Some exposure studies have used active workers, but these groups are more likely to include more healthy workers, since compromised workers were more likely to have left the job or retired, the study said.

Erika Sabbath

"[W]hat was really striking was that we also saw some cognitive problems in those who had been highly exposed much longer ago, up to 50 years before testing," said Dr. Erika Sabbath.

"I’m very excited about this work reaching those in industries that use solvents regularly.

"Because cognitive problems at older ages are so common—but there are very few treatments—it’s important to do everything we can to reduce known contributors to these problems at older ages," Sabbath told PaintSquare News.

"Employers and supervisors who use solvents in their work are in a unique position to be able to make a real difference in the types and concentrations of solvents to which workers are exposed.”

The study does not make recommendations for reducing exposures. For those, Sabbath said, she defers to industrial hygienists.


Tagged categories: Health & Safety; Health and safety; Marine Coatings; Personal protective equipment; Protective Coatings; Solvent and chemical cleaning; Solventborne coatings; Solvents; Workers

Comment from jan Maurits Schouten, (5/14/2014, 4:53 AM)

I am really surprised that this is presented as news. In Europe the effects of solvents on neurological damages is considered as being scientifical proven for a long time. European ann national laws are aimed at reducing or even abandoning solvents in paints. In The Netherlands it is even forbidden to paint in-house with solvent-born paints.

Comment from Dan Chute, (5/14/2014, 10:46 AM)

As an Industrial Hygienist for the past 35 years, I always explore beyond the headlines when I see some new and startling hazard revelations before running down the street like my hair was on fire. It's important to understand what type of test served as the determinant of "brain damage," what measures of solvent exposure and type were used, what type of control group comparisons were used, and what "qualifiers" were used in the conclusions which often state...these findings are preliminary, therefore more research is needed to get a better picture.... Still, as health and safety professionals and business-smart contractors, we should always seek ways to work more cleanly and efficiently to get more paint on the steel and less on the cars below and up the noses of the adjacent workforce. I'm volunteering for the study that finds industrial painting causes hair loss.

Comment from peter gibson, (5/14/2014, 3:22 PM)

Call Ms. Sabbath...she has all the answers. Another idiotic study not related to the real world. these painters are out of shape and going downhill anyway.

Comment from Simon Hope, (5/15/2014, 4:15 AM)

What?? Do I come here often?? I think that it is fairly well documented that solvents cause serious neurological problems both short and long term hence the drive to reduce their use and outlaw many of he more viscious ones that we used to use. Eventually i hope that all systems will be either solvent free or water based thus ensuring the safety and longevity of our workforce for the future.

Comment from M. Halliwell, (5/15/2014, 11:02 AM)

@Dan - I agree that more information would be nice...but how often do you get that in a newspaper type of article? It would definitely be worth looking at the actual journal article for more info. @Peter - Although I agree that society as a whole appears to be getting more out of shape, I think you'd need to cite a study linking obesity and/or lack of physical activity to cognitive imparement before dismissing Ms. Sabbath's study lightly. Considering the carcinogenic links with many solvents, is it that hard to believe that they could have long term impacts on the brain too?

Comment from Billy Russell, (5/16/2014, 10:08 PM)

I knew it ! that explains my Bipolar mood swings, smiling

Comment from Michael Deaton, (5/17/2014, 10:40 AM)

After spraying and mixing massive amounts of every kind of paint imaginable,i can verify first hand that inhaling vapors from painting/mixing operations has affected myself and my brothers in this trade. I began spraying offshore drilling rigs and production platforms in 1986 and respirators were available but very seldom used and replaced with a simple head rag. We would be spraying G500 wash primer ahead of the vinyls, 8 or 10 of us, working 75' above the water, and i can remember my spine going numb and I looked around and everybody was sitting on their pics laughing without a clue of what we were laughing at. Painters on average have some type of dependency which can be linked directly to inhalation of paint fumes, whether its alcohol or some other vice. Hard truth but reality....

Comment from Karen Fischer, (5/20/2014, 9:14 AM)

This surprises me to, being considered "news". Health effects to chemical vapors has been known for a lot time here as well. I remember wearing a respirator in my College Chemistry Lab in the mid 1970's or setting up my equipment in the exhaust hood. No surprise here....or then. Halogenated Hydrocarbons have always been known to cause problems along with other chemical vapors.

Comment Join the Conversation:

Sign in to our community to add your comments.

Tarps manufacturing, Inc.


Paint BidTracker

NLB Corporation

HoldTight Solutions Inc.

Modern Safety Techniques

Sauereisen, Inc.

Strand’s Industrial Coatings


Technology Publishing Co., 1501 Reedsdale Street, Suite 2008, Pittsburgh, PA 15233

TEL 1-412-431-8300  • FAX  1-412-431-5428  •  EMAIL

The Technology Publishing Network

PaintSquare the Journal of Protective Coatings & Linings Paint BidTracker

EXPLORE:      JPCL   |   PaintSquare News   |   Interact   |   Buying Guides   |   Webinars   |   Resources   |   Classifieds
REGISTER AND SUBSCRIBE:      Free PaintSquare Registration   |   Subscribe to JPCL   |   Subscribe to PaintSquare News
MORE:      About   |   Privacy Policy   |   Terms & Conditions   |   Support   |   Site Map   |   Search   |   Contact Us