Coatings Industry News

Main News Page

Hospital Cleanup Draws $2.3M Fine

Wednesday, April 9, 2014

Comment | More

Federal authorities have shut down and fined an intensive cleanup project at an old psychiatric hospital complex in New York, following complaints about dangerous lead and asbestos practices there.

The federal actions came in response to work underway at the old Harlem Valley Psychiatric Hospital, a decaying and long-shuttered 900-acre site under what The New York Times calls "mysterious" new ownership.

The Occupational Safety and Health Administration has slapped owner Olivet Management LLC with 46 citations and nearly $2.4 million in fines over the project.

Harlem Valley Psych Hospital Harlem Valley Hospital site - 2013
Flickr / 826 PARANORMAL (left); Olivet Management LLC (right)

The former Harlem Valley Psychiatric Hospital dates to the 1920s and closed in the 1990s. Left: Part of the complex in August 2010, before cleanup.  Right: Another building after the cleanup in 2013. The EPA halted the cleanup in January.

Meanwhile, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has ordered Olivet to stop all asbestos work at the site and submit a legal cleanup plan.

Intensive Cleanup

The cleanup, and the questions, began last year when Olivet Management decided that the site's 80 crumbling brick buildings needed to be spruced up in short order so that potential investors could tour the property north of New York City

The management firm called in 13 contractors, as well as some of its own employees.

Together, the crews tackled peeling paint, buckled ceilings and walls, decrepit windows and doors, broken tiles and floors, filthy carpets, and tons of other toxin-riddled materials that had been untouched since the state closed the hospital 20 years before.

But never, federal authorities say, did property owner Olivet Management tell any of the companies or workers that the scores of 90-year-old buildings were filled with lead and asbestos.

Instead, under Olivet's supervision, the crews worked—untrained, unprotected and unaware, according to authorities—to scrape paint, break down and haul away debris, and otherwise prepare the complex for redevelopment as The Olivet Center, billed as an education, IT and research center.


All but one of the new OSHA citations are classified as willful, OSHA's highest level of infraction, reserved for flagrant violations of the law and "plain indifference" to employee safety and health.

Harlem Valley Psych Hospital Harlem Valley Psych Hospital - 2013
Flickr / 826 PARANORMAL (left); Olivet Management LLC (right)

The 900-acre complex, with 80 brick buildings, was abandoned for 20 years. Olivet Management LLC, of Dover, NY, is trying to redevelop the complex. In October, a New York Times article about the project called the developer "mysterious."

"Olivet knew that asbestos and lead were present at this site, yet the company chose to ignore its responsibility to protect its own workers and contractors," U.S. Secretary of Labor Thomas E. Perez said in an announcement  Wednesday (April 2).

"The intolerable choice this company made put not only workers, but also their families, in danger."


Olivet describes itself on its website as a "real estate development and management company specializing in school and commercial properties across the United States."

But the site contains few specifics and no company history; and only the Olivet Center project is clearly identified in its project portfolio. In October, The New York Times published an article that referred to Olivet Management as the hospital site's "mysterious new owner."

The newspaper said the site would be redeveloped in part as a satellite campus for Olivet University, a small Christian college in San Francisco. The paper described the university's founder, a Korean pastor named David Jang, as an associate of the Rev. Sun Myung Moon, founder of the Unification Church.

Olivet Center rendering
Olivet Management LLC

Olivet Management says the site will become an education, IT and research center. The New York Times said the site will include a satellite campus for a San Francisco university led by a messianic pastor.

The Times also cited a lengthy 2012 article by Christianity Today, which reported that Jang's followers "encourage the belief that he's the 'Second Coming Christ.'"

Company Responds

In a statement Thursday (April 3), Olivet Management spokeswoman Anna Oh said the company was reviewing the OSHA citations "in the hope of working with the agency to resolve them."

Oh said that her company was "new to New York State" and "grateful for the direction we have been given by both state and federal agencies in helping us move forward with our long-term commitment to bring economic development, stability and vibrancy and new jobs to the area in the most effective and efficient manner as possible."

The statement added: "We have the same goals as OSHA—to ensure that once construction and renovation work is commenced, all workers will be fully protected against any unsafe and unhealthful working conditions."

Asbestos cleanup

Asbestos professionals must be trained and certified. According to OSHA, workers at the Olivet site removed and hauled asbestos waste with no training, no protective gear and no knowledge of the asbestos located throughout the property.

The company said it looked "forward to moving forward on a project that we believe will help restore economic energy to the greater Harlem Valley region and to a project we at Olivet Management are committed to for the long term."

Willful Citations

OSHA's Albany, NY, office began inspecting the site Oct. 23, 2013, in response to a complaint. According to the EPA, inspectors were initially refused access to the site, but were allowed in days later.

The OSHA inspection found that employees and contractors "directed and overseen" by Olivet supervisors were performing renovation and cleanup activities that included "removing asbestos- and lead-contaminated debris; asbestos-containing floor tiles and insulation; and lead-containing paint from walls, windows, door frames and other painted surfaces."

The EPA said that "many of the buildings contained significant amounts of asbestos."

OSHA determined that Olivet "knowingly failed to take basic safety precautions. The company neither informed their own employees nor the contractors about the presence of asbestos and lead, despite knowing that both hazards existed."

Lead Paint

The complex's buildings dated to the 1920s, with an abundance of lead paint, according to OSHA. The window pictured is not from the site.

The 77-page list of violations details allegations that Olivet failed to:

  • Train employees in the hazards of asbestos and lead and the need and nature of required safeguards;
  • Monitor workers’ exposure levels;
  • Provide appropriate respiratory protection;
  • Post notices, warning signs and labels to alert workers and contractors to the presence of asbestos and lead; and
  • Provide clean changing and decontamination areas for workers, many of whom wore their contaminated clothing home to households with small children.

Other Actions

Nor did the company inform waste haulers of the presence of asbestos and asbestos-containg materials, "meaning asbestos from the site may have been disposed of improperly at an unknown location," according to OSHA.

This lack of notice prompted the one serious violation in the case.

Due to the high number of willful violations, Olivet has been placed in OSHA's Severe Violator Enforcement Program, which targets enforcement resources toward "recalcitrant" employers.


Tagged categories: Asbestos; Brick; Cleanup; Hazardous waste; Health & Safety; Health and safety; Health Care/Hospitals; Historic Structures; Lead paint abatement; Maintenance coating work; Maintenance programs; OSHA; Renovation

Comment Join the Conversation:

Sign in to our community to add your comments.

Axxiom Manufacturing

Abrasives Inc.


KTA-Tator, Inc. - Corporate Office

HoldTight Solutions Inc.


Western Technology Inc.

Sauereisen, Inc.


Technology Publishing Co., 1501 Reedsdale Street, Suite 2008, Pittsburgh, PA 15233

TEL 1-412-431-8300  • FAX  1-412-431-5428  •  EMAIL

The Technology Publishing Network

PaintSquare the Journal of Protective Coatings & Linings Paint BidTracker

EXPLORE:      JPCL   |   PaintSquare News   |   Interact   |   Buying Guides   |   Webinars   |   Resources   |   Classifieds
REGISTER AND SUBSCRIBE:      Free PaintSquare Registration   |   Subscribe to JPCL   |   Subscribe to PaintSquare News
MORE:      About   |   Privacy Policy   |   Terms & Conditions   |   Support   |   Site Map   |   Search   |   Contact Us