PAINTSQUARE BLOG

Comment |

A Tale of Two Clients

WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 18, 2015

By Warren Brand


When a Sag Is Not a Sag

There’s a concept in martial arts that the first time a student sees a punch, it is just a punch. But then, as the student begins to learn the nuances of the punch—say, a right cross—the punch becomes a complex, intimidating almost unfathomable thing.  And the beginner’s punch is really no punch at all.

To deliver a right cross properly, the student must learn to keep the heel of the back foot off the ground and pivot on the toes, like squishing a bug or putting out a cigarette, to engage the hips. 

The pupil must learn to twist the body and not lean, for to lean is to lose one’s balance and present it as a gift to your opponent. The student needs to learn to raise the right shoulder to protect the right side of the chin from a hook. The student must learn to keep the left hand up, relax until impact, breath at the right moment, and on and on and on.

Then, after many years of training, the punch is once again just a punch.

Client 1 – The Sag

We had been working on the lining of the interior of a 60-by-40-foot-tall open-top floating roof tank. Our scope was:

  • Identification of an optimal corrosion mitigation system;
  • Development of site-specific, asset-specific specifications;
  • Inspection; and
  • Ongoing consulting as required.

The coating system we specified was a 100-percent solids epoxy requiring plural component equipment to spray at 40-60 mils dry film thickness (DFT). Surface prep was SSPC-5, NACE 1.

The contractor, while competent, was not accustomed to spraying with a plural component system, so, to supplement their efforts, we arranged to have a separate technician onsite for startup.

As with most coating projects, it seems, there were issues with temperature (dancing around the critical 55°F mark), equipment, logistics and in-line heaters. So when they first started spraying, before they were able to get a good spray fan, the material was applied too thick, and it ran.

Warren Brand
Warren Brand

Sags from spraying plural component material before a good fan spray had been established.

The resulting sags, like the right cross, was something I was intimately familiar with. I have personally sprayed thousands of gallons of these types of materials and knew, from experience, that they were of no technical consequence and long as:

  • The run and areas immediately surrounding it were holiday-free;
  • It was a 100-percent solids material (no risk of solvent entrapment);
  • The area just above the sag was at the minimal DFT identified in the specificaiton;
  • It was not an area where the floating roof would travel; and
  • The coating had properly cured.

I knew—and received confirmation in writing from the material supplier—that the sag would have no impact on the performance or durability of the coating system, despite the fact that it was clearly beyond a 40-mil DFT.

We certainly could have recommended that the contractor remove the sags, but we were on a very tight schedule and were trying to move the project along.

Looking back now, being that hindsight is 20/20, this was akin to one of my martial arts students asking why they couldn’t lean into a punch. Except I, being overly self-confident, didn’t even think to ask any other questions. 

I failed to see the sag for what it really was—and what it really meant in this specific case.

Warren Brand
Warren Brand

Author’s own saggy handiwork from about 15 years ago; area being spark-tested. In this case, we intentionally over-sprayed the coating system due to the severely pitted and corroded substrate. This tank remains in service and the coating pristine.

The sag, and there were a handful of others, was on the far side of the open-top floating roof tank a few feet from the top. It was at the exact opposite side of where the winding hot-dip galvanized (HDG) coated walkway wound around the tank and ended in a platform overlooking the sags. It was, in essence, the first thing that caught your eye as you climbed up the last few steps and onto the landing.

They could not have been more conspicuous.

I was recently called out to a meeting on a Monday (Nov. 9), where the owner asked about the sags. I explained the technical issues surrounding them, and he took me aside and said: “We’ve just spent over a million dollars on this project. This is an area where reliability engineers and operators will come and look at this tank for decades.” (We designed the coating system to last well in excess of 15 years.)

“Every time a new engineer looks at this tank, I’m going to get a phone call or email asking if the paint is peeling or damaged,” he continued. “When the plant manager or anyone else looks at this, they’re going to wonder what kind of paint job this was and who did it.”

I felt sheepish and ashamed. How did I not think of this on my own? I’ll tell you: because I was overconfident. I was like the student throwing a first punch while thinking he knew what a punch was.

But I could not have been more wrong. In a world where perception is reality, I had dropped the ball. I had leaned into my right cross, lost my balance and faltered.

iStock.com / Viktor_Gladkov
© iStock.com / Viktor_Gladkov

In a world where perception is reality, I had dropped the ball. I had leaned into my right cross, lost my balance and faltered.

I had been so focused on what I knew, that I didn’t even consider what I didn’t.

When I first started my consultancy a few years ago, I had some very specific ideas of how to do things. In fact, quoting from my own literature: “Each project is a completely new undertaking, and must be addressed as such.”

Client 2 – The Complexity of the Distressed Floor

In contrast, another project we started recently had to do with a distressed floor.

For those of us who have worked on failure analysis of these types, I can think of nothing more complicated.

Concrete, by its nature, is a complex amalgam of stuff that can vary from pour to pour and, on occasion, within a single pour. Moisture content, humidity, temperature, admixtures, air entrainment and myriad other concerns come into play in evaluating a coating failure—and that’s even before you start to look at the coating system itself.

I’m not a petrographer or chemist, but I was required to pour through hundreds of pages of documents, photos, conflicting technical reports, petrographic analysis and references to a wide range of standards, including ASTM 5084, ASTM F-1869, ASTM F2170 and many more.

While this was not new to me, it was far more complex than the sag, so I studied everything much more closely. I asked many more questions. I lived up to the promise in my literature that “Each project is a completely new undertaking, and must be addressed as such.”

Wikimedia Commons / Polyparadigm [Public Domain]
By Polyparadigm / Public domain via Wikimedia Commons

Concrete, by its nature, is a complex amalgam of stuff that can vary from pour to pour and, on occasion, within a single pour.

And, because I was looking at this project from a new perspective and not being complacent or overconfident in my thinking, I will be—and am currently—better able to provide solutions.

I work with coating professionals, owners, technicians, inspectors, sales reps and others in our industry on a daily basis. I find, as with seasoned martial arts instructors, that the most competent are those who give their opinions, yet are open to alternative views. They are patient with questions and generous with their time. 

The sag on the interior of the tank will haunt me for the next 15 years. It will be a reminder of the dangers of hubris—and will motivate me to do better. And isn’t that all we can do with any endeavor? To try to do better?

ABOUT THE BLOGGER

Warren Brand

Warren Brand’s coatings career has ranged from entry-level field painting to the presidency of two successful companies. Over nearly three decades, he has project-managed thousands of coating installations and developed specs for thousands of paint and coating applications. NACE Level 3 and SSPC PCS certified, Brand, an MBA and martial-arts instructor, now heads Chicago Corrosion Group, a leading coatings consultancy. Contact Warren.

SEE ALL CONTENT FROM THIS CONTRIUBTOR

   

Tagged categories: Coating Materials; Consultants; NACE; Protective Coating Specialist (PCS); Protective coatings; Specification writing; SSPC; Asia Pacific; Coating / Film thickness; Coating Application; Coating failure; Coating inspection; Coating/Film Thickness; Coating/Film Thickness; Concrete coatings and treatments; Dry Film Thickness (DFT); EMEA (Europe, Middle East and Africa); Latin America; North America; Overspray; Runs, sags, curtains or "sliding"; Tank exteriors

Comment from Christine Gunsaullus, (11/19/2015, 7:55 AM)

Great stories! Every project has issues, and you try to resolve each one to the owners' satisfaction. Ideally, a contractor who "is not accustomed" to the plural component systems would not even bid. Qualifications can be added to all specs, public and private, to make sure your job isn't practice. And the qualifications need to be tough, particularly for these coatings that take a lot of practice and understanding not only to apply, but also to run the equipment and mix correctly. Granted, you weigh many variables over the course of a project, and a tight schedule sometimes leads you to accept something that's not perfect - it will get the job done, but it's not perfect. So a great reminder to get the owner's input for odd-ball stuff like this, to understand how important is aesthetics in this situation. Christine Gunsaullus entecheng.com


Comment from trevor neale, (11/19/2015, 8:28 AM)

Lots of lessons to be be learnt here. I would have thought that SSPA PA 1 had it been includued in the specifications, would have precluded the acceptence of the heavily sagged areas


Comment from Guy Tyrrell, (11/19/2015, 8:52 AM)

As the father of a 17 yr old black belt, I absolutely love the opening.


Comment from Anand Karamandi, (11/19/2015, 9:23 AM)

We all learn new lessons daily. After 34 years in the coating business I still learn. Sometimes, we are bound to forget small things because our focus is on other. How come the contractor did not fix the sag then & there itself when they realized it. It would had been lot easier. I totally agree with some of the comments above that the contractor must have experience using plural equipment and the guys who pulls the trigger.


Comment from M. Halliwell, (11/19/2015, 11:13 AM)

Anand, between your "pulls the trigger" comment and Warren's martial arts analogy...I feel right at home :) I, too, have extensive martial arts experience, but also time in uniform and as a competitive archer. The premise that every job (or shot) is unique and must be handled as such, and that "just a ____" never really applies, is something I try to always remember myself and instill to those I now help mentor and supervise. Keep up the good work, Warren.


Comment from Troy Williams, (11/19/2015, 5:22 PM)

I recently watched my brother and another coatings applicator applying a two part coating where the cartridges were heated before application Every time they would get a new cartridge they would spray a piece of cardboard or waste for about ten seconds before they would attempt to spray the substrate. I didn't see any runs at all. Maybe the contractor was unfamiliar with this type of application. The aesthetic value is also important


Comment Join the Conversation:

Sign in to our community to add your comments.

Advertisements
 
Mitsubishi Gas Chemical America

 
KTA-Tator, Inc. - Corporate Office

 
DeFelsko Corporation

 
Fischer Technology Inc.

 
SABRE Autonomous Solutions

 
NLB Corporation

 
Tarps manufacturing, Inc.

 
SAFE Systems, Inc.

 
Modern Safety Techniques

 
 
 

Technology Publishing Co., 1501 Reedsdale Street, Suite 2008, Pittsburgh, PA 15233

TEL 1-412-431-8300  • FAX  1-412-431-5428  •  EMAIL webmaster@paintsquare.com


The Technology Publishing Network

PaintSquare the Journal of Protective Coatings & Linings Paint BidTracker

 
EXPLORE:      JPCL   |   PaintSquare News   |   Interact   |   Buying Guides   |   Webinars   |   Resources   |   Classifieds
REGISTER AND SUBSCRIBE:      Free PaintSquare Registration   |   Subscribe to JPCL   |   Subscribe to PaintSquare News
MORE:      About PaintSquare.com   |   Privacy Policy   |   Terms & Conditions   |   Support   |   Site Map   |   Search   |   Contact Us