PaintSquare.com
      | Connect Follow us on Twitter Like us on Facebook
About | Subscribe | Advertise
  

 

Download our free e-book! Corrosion Under Insulation. Sponsored by Thermion.

Problem Solving Forum

| More

May 2 - May 8, 2011

A specification requires Manufacturer X’s system “or equivalent.” What does “or equivalent” mean, and who decides what’s “equivalent?”



More items for Quality Control


Selected Answers

From Frank Rea of GPI-Southeast on May 3, 2011:
     Coatings or coatings systems can be evaluated for equivalence to a specified product by any or a combination of the following criteria: generic type of resin, chemical and phyical properties, service environment, required surface preparation, compatibility with existing coatings (if applicable), formula, or performance. The specifier should be the individual to determine whether a proposed alternative is "equivalent".

From Joseph Schinner of Akzo Nobel Coatings Inc. on May 2, 2011:

     I've dealt with federal, state, architectural, engineering, and general manufacturer's specifications for different types of coatings. It can be a mushball or it can be relatively simple. The detail of the spec itself determines how to approach the equivalent.

     The most common "equivalent" is a performance equivalent that may or may not spell out a generic binder type. If a binder is not identified, then you are free to use what you want to match the preformance, but it is always advisable to know what the competitor is using and why it seems to fulfill the requirements before deviating from his lead.

     If a spec asks for a 2K epoxy or a single package acrylic, then it doesn't want a performance equivalent in another generic binder system unless you can specifically sell them on value-added qualities that they will accept for their end use. It is best to find someone at the customer's facility who can answer questions about what application/field problems have been encountered and solved that are not directly addressed in the spec tests themselves. Often, this is where  "equivalents" can be a struggle until the "hidden specs" are solved. As examples, the specs may not address certain part-handling mar problems, or the finished structure may have temporary ponded water areas with no mention of immersion testing needed. Spec "equivalent" ranges all the way from a DOD spec that may specify coating formulas with specific binder/pigment/solvent types/ratios including exact hydrogen-amine ratios all the way to simple gross (e.g., anything that won't fall off the wall for 5 yrs. and still look white).

     Note: the more specific the formulation spec is, the more likely it was written around the competitor's or his predecessor's actual formula or submission, making it seem easier to match, but these are sometimes the hardest to overcome the "tricks" built in to prevent an easy match.

From Brian Chapman of Cadillac Fabrication on May 2, 2011:
     We generally take this to mean a coating that CLOSELY matches the spec in performance. The equivalent should be decided by the manufacturer's rep for the coating you want to use, based soley on performance characteristics.

Please sign in to submit your answer this question    

Tagged categories: Specification writing


Current PSF Question | Submit a PSF Question | Full PSF Archive

DeFelsko Corporation
PosiTector Inspection Kits

PosiTector 6000 Coating Thickness Gage easily converts to a surface profile gage, dew point meter or ultrasonic wall thickness gage with a simple probe change


Fischer Technology Inc.
DUALSCOPE®FMP100 with DataCenter IP

Transfer customized inspection plans from PC to FMP100 using step-by-step guidance with prompts and pictures throughout the measurement procedure


Sika-Us
Sika® Industrial Floor Coatings

Click to learn about floor and wall systems relied upon for performance, durability, easy maintenance and aesthetics across the every industry and environment.


NACE International, The Corrosion Society
Get the Basics Anytime, Anywhere!

Take this online training to eliminate juggling your work schedule with continuous education. Learn corrosion causes, types, and how it can be controlled.


HoldTight Solutions Inc.
NO FLASH RUST - NO CONTAMINANTS

Our HoldTight®102 salt remover & flash rust
preventer prevents flash
rust by removing surface contaminants. Contact us
for your nearest distributor.
(800) 319.8802 sales@holdtight.com


KTA-Tator, Inc. - Corporate Office
KTA-TATOR LABORATORY SERVICES

• Coating failure analysis
• Independent
  comparative testing
• Accelerated
  weathering testing
• Toxic metals testing
• A2LA Accredited
Contact: Cindy O'Malley,
at 412-788-1300 x180


Mitsubishi Gas Chemical America
Performance Amine 1,3-BAC

A highly reactive cycloaliphatic diamine offering superior performance. Reasonable cost and curing efficacy makes it suitable for all types of epoxy resin applications.


Axxiom Manufacturing
Schmidt Introduces
the New miniBRS

Reduced in size, it is incredibly easy to maneuver and operate! The perfect alternative to larger blast & recovery units when project space is limited.
Call 1-800-231-2085


Modern Safety Techniques
Modern Safety Techniques

See our Low Temperature Catalyst for your CO removal needs. Help to provide your workers with safe, comfortable breathing air!


Abrasives Inc.
Check our Prices for Blast Abrasives

Faced with higher abrasive costs? We invite you to call & check our rates on Black Magic® coal slag and other quality blast materials. Abrasives Inc. 800-584-7524

 
 
 
Technology Publishing

The Technology Publishing Network

The Journal of Protective Coatings & Linings (JPCL) PaintSquare
Durability + Design Paint BidTracker

 
EXPLORE:      JPCL   |   PaintSquare News   |   Interact   |   Buying Guides   |   Webinars   |   Resources   |   Classifieds
REGISTER AND SUBSCRIBE:      Free PaintSquare Registration   |   Subscribe to JPCL   |   Subscribe to PaintSquare News
MORE:      About PaintSquare.com   |   Privacy policy   |   Terms & conditions   |   Site Map   |   Search   |   Contact Us
 

© Copyright 2000-2016, Technology Publishing / PaintSquare, All rights reserved
2100 Wharton Street, Suite 310, Pittsburgh PA 15203-1951; Tel 1-412-431-8300; Fax 1-412-431-5428; E-mail webmaster@paintsquare.com