PaintSquare.com


The First Word in Protective & Marine Coatings

A Product of Technology Publishing / PaintSquare
JPCL | PaintSquare News | Durability + Design | Paint BidTracker

Paint and Coatings Industry News

Main News Page


BBB Slaps Sherwin-Williams’ VOC Claim

Wednesday, January 19, 2011

More items for Coating Materials

Comment | More

Sherwin-Williams Harmony

Prompted by a challenge from Benjamin Moore & Co., the Council of Better Business Bureaus’ ad arm has recommended that The Sherwin-Williams Co. drop its zero-VOC claim about the Harmony paint line.
 
This is the second time in less than a year that the Council’s National Advertising Division has intervened on a Sherwin-Williams product claim.

In the current case, NAD urged Sherwin-Williams to “modify or discontinue advertising claims that the ‘Harmony’ paint line is completely free of volatile organic compounds (VOCs).”

NAD, the advertising industry’s self-regulatory forum, announced the decision after reviewing express and implied claims made by Sherwin-Williams in website and print advertising.

Sherwin-Williams said in a statement that it was disappointed by the decision but “out of respect for the self-regulatory process,” would accept the decision and “take the NAD’s findings into consideration in its future advertising for Harmony paint.”

Claims Challenged

Benjamin Moore challenged these express claims:

• “No-VOC formula.”

• “Zero-VOC formula.”

• “Formulated without silica and without VOCs for better indoor air quality.”

NAD also “reviewed the implied claim that the full line of Sherwin-Williams Harmony paints, including base paint and paint containing color, contain no VOCs.”

In a 15-page decision released late Tuesday (Jan. 18), NAD noted that although Harmony’s Deep and Extra White base coats contained less than 5.0 grams per liter (g/L) VOC, all tinted varieties tested showed coating VOC content ranging from 42 g/L to 112 g/L—“significantly higher than” the 5.0 g/L threshold generally established for zero-VOC claims.

The testing was conducted by CalPoly at Benjamin Moore’s request.

Consumers ‘Falsely Told’

“The challenger emphasized that Sherwin-Williams’ advertising does not in any way communicate to the consumer that the Zero-VOC claims refer only to the base paint, and not to the paint with the added colorants which the consumer actually purchases at the point of sale,” NAD noted.

“Thus, consumers are being falsely told that the paint which they will bring home and apply to their walls is VOC free when, in fact, it has significant levels of VOCs.”

Because Sherwin-Williams advertises only colored applications of Harmony, the ads should indicate that the zero-VOC claim does not apply to colorants, NAD found.

Sherwin-Williams’ Response

In responding to NAD, Sherwin-Williams contended that its EnviroToners colorant kept the Harmony VOC threshold below 5.0 g/L, but NAD noted that EnviroToners are available in only 28% of Sherwin-Williams stores.

NAD also rejected Sherwin-Williams’ claim that Benjamin Moore had singled out “atypical, unpopular” colors “with the aim of finding outliers” that exceeded the VOC threshold.

Sherwin-Williams attacked CalPoly’s test methods and results, but admitted that “certain colors” in the Harmony line would exceed the 5.0 g/L VOC threshold when its Deep Base was mixed with conventional colorants, NAD said.

The company maintained, however, that its zero-VOC claims were substantiated as to the entire Harmony line because the majority of the line fell below the 5.0 g/L threshold.

NAD rejected that contention as well, determining that the company’s “claim of ‘zero-VOC’ was a line claim for the full line of Harmony paints after the addition of colorants.”

The evidence “demonstrates that not all of the paint colors in the Harmony line perform as promised when Sherwin-Williams’ Deep Base is mixed with conventional colorants,” NAD said.

NAD recommended that Sherwin-Williams drop or change the claim “by clearly and conspicuously disclosing that the addition of conventional colorants to Harmony Deep Base paint may result in higher levels of VOCs for some colors.”

Refresh Claims

The Harmony case is Sherwin-Williams’ second rebuke by NAD in the last year. In March 2010, NAD recommended that Sherwin-Williams “modify or discontinue” claims that its Dutch Boy Refresh Paint eliminated odors. All of the Refresh paint advertisements featured the “odor-eliminating technology” symbol.

That successful challenge had been filed by PPG Architectural Finishes Inc.

NAD concluded that the claims conveyed the message that Refresh paint would reduce odors to a level that is not detectable to the average consumer —a message that Sherwin-Williams’ evidence did not support, it said.

Heat Rising on Green Claims

NAD has recently seen a rise in adjudication of environmental claims for a wide variety of products—from soup to Internet services to HDTV, said Linda Bean, Director of Communication.

NAD “supports innovation and the right of companies to promote new and innovative features of their products,” Bean said.

However, she added: “In fast-moving and dynamic industries, there is often fierce competition to distinguish consumer-relevant product features—and competitors keep a very close eye on the advertising claims made in the marketplace.”

“So, as the paint and coatings industry seeks to meet evolving consumer needs, it is not unexpected that there would multiple challenges.”

   

Tagged categories: Advertising; Green coatings; Low-VOC; Sherwin-Williams; VOC content; VOC-free

Comment from Tim Johnes, (1/20/2011, 1:01 PM)

Typical SW arrogance.


Comment from Tommy Johnson, (1/20/2011, 2:42 PM)

It would seem SWP is behind in moving to 0 voc colorants.


Comment from Nancy Boguszewski, (1/22/2011, 8:02 PM)

Seems BM & PPG are worried about their existence.


Comment from Gary OConnor, (1/25/2011, 2:58 PM)

I am certain this is inaccurate; SW would NEVER intentionally mislead the consumer!


Comment Join the Conversation:

Sign in to our community to add your comments.

BASF
New resins from BASF will have metals loving water:

Excellent corrosion resistance, low VOC, high gloss, thin films basf.us/industrialcoatings
polyorders@basf.com
800-231-7868


Sherwin-Williams
Sherwin Williams

• Extends Service Life
• Single Coat Application
• Cure to Service in 24 Hours


International Paint LLC

International Paint Engineered Coatings

Learn about our solutions for:
  • Structural Steel
  • Piping & Equipment
  • Storage Tanks
  • Pressure Vessels
  • Secondary Containment


    Polyval Coatings
    Polyflex® Polyurea Linings

    exhibit outstanding versatility in use; providing abrasion resistance, superior seamless waterproofing and high-chem corrosion protection. www.polyflexlinings.com


    Mitsubishi Gas Chemical America
    Performance Amine 1,3-BAC

    A highly reactive cycloaliphatic diamine offering superior performance. Reasonable cost and curing efficacy makes it suitable for all types of epoxy resin applications.


    Wasser High-Tech Coatings Inc.
    Wasser Coatings Protect

    some of the most important bridges in the country; learn about our NEPCOAT-approved system and our entire range of MCU & Polyurea coatings. 1-800-627-2968 www.wassercoatings.com


    SAFE Systems, Inc.
    Enduroguard -
    The Tough Cable
    for a Tough Industry.

    Reduce maintenance costs and down time, increase job site safety with Enduroguard Cable. Available exclusively from SAFE Systems. UL listed, flexible, abrasion resistant and cut resistant.

  •  
     
     
    Technology Publishing

    The Technology Publishing Network

    The Journal of Protective Coatings & Linings (JPCL) PaintSquare
    Durability + Design Paint BidTracker JPCL Europe

     
    EXPLORE:      JPCL   |   PaintSquare News   |   Interact   |   Buying Guides   |   Webinars   |   Resources   |   Classifieds
    REGISTER AND SUBSCRIBE:      Free PaintSquare Registration   |   Subscribe to JPCL   |   Subscribe to PaintSquare News
    MORE:      About PaintSquare.com   |   Privacy policy   |   Terms & conditions   |   Site Map   |   Search   |   Contact Us
     

    © Copyright 2000-2014, Technology Publishing / PaintSquare, All rights reserved
    2100 Wharton Street, Suite 310, Pittsburgh PA 15203-1951; Tel 1-412-431-8300; Fax 1-412-431-5428; E-mail webmaster@paintsquare.com