PaintSquare.com
Follow us on Twitter Follow us on LinkedIn Like us on Facebook Follow us on Instagram Visit the TPC Store
Search the site

 

Advertisement

PaintSquare


Coatings Industry News

Main News Page


Ike Memorial Panned as ‘5-Star Folly’

Tuesday, September 2, 2014

Comment | More

After 15 years, $65 million in appropriations, and not a shovel of dirt turned, the Dwight D. Eisenhower Memorial Commission can add a congressional oversight panel to its growing list of critics.

Congress has already cut construction funding, and even the Eisenhower family has objected to the execution of the memorial, which was conceived as a six-year, $100 million project.

Now, the controversial project has been dissected in a scathing staff report by the U.S. House Committee on Natural Resources.

Eisenhower Memorial EisenhowerMemorial
Eisenhower Memorial Commission

The four-acre site would be framed by three stainless-steel tapestries featuring scenery from Kansas. The tapestries would be supported by a colonnade of limestone-clad columns 80 feet tall.

The details consume 58 pages, but the committee makes its point in the title: A Five-Star Folly: An Investigation into the Cost Increases, Construction Delays, and Design Problems that Have Been a Disservice to the Effort to Memorialize Dwight D. Eisenhower.

The findings include allegations that the commission has:

  • Paid more than $1.4 million to fundraising companies that have raised less than $500,000 toward a $35 million goal;
  • Awarded several contracts to sole-source vendors without an open competition; and
  • Modified "almost every contract" multiple times, to the tune of "millions of dollars in additional costs."

'Repeated Failure'

Although not officially adopted by the committee, the staff report is a detailed indictment of the time and resources expended on the 15-year-old memorial project: from its "unprecedented" design selection process, to its "repeated failure to satisfy all legal requirements," to its "unanticipated costs and delays due to conversial elements of the selected design."

The report raises "significant questions that undermine the viability" of the controversial Frank Gehry design to memorialize the nation's 34th President and Supreme Commander of the Allied Forces in Europe during World War II.

The report is merely the latest chorus of criticism about the project's design and progress. Other critics include:

The 12-member Memorial Commission was established in 1999 and did not select a site until 2005. It selected the Gehry design in 2008 after a competition. Gehry, now 85, says he had not designed a memorial before but was intrigued by Eisenhower.

Honoring Ike

Critics are not challenging the merits of the project—just its execution.

IkeMemorial
Eisenhower Memorial Commission

Critics, including the Eisenhower family, call the design too elaborate and expensive, with unknown maintenance costs. The design also violates guidelines laid down years before it was submitted for approval.

"Everyone, critics and advocates alike, want a memorial, a monument, that truly honors President Eisenhower and helps future generations of Americans undersand and appreciate his role in American history," U.S. Rep. Rob Bishop (R-UT) told an oversight hearing on the project in 2012.

That's about all critics and advocates agree on, however. The design, critics say, is too elaborate, too expensive, and too vulnerable to the elements. And the process, they say, has been unaccountable and out of control.

The four-acre site off the National Mall would be framed by three stainless-steel tapestries featuring scenery from Kansas. The tapestries would be supported by a colonnade of limestone-clad columns 80 feet tall and 10 feet in diameter.

The memorial’s core would feature limestone bas-relief blocks, free-standing bronze sculpture, quotations that honor Eisenhower, and a 2,400-square-foot visitor center.

$65.4M Appropriation

Congress has appropriated about $65.4 million for the project since the commission was established. More than  $40 million of that has been spent, the report says.

Not only has construction not begun, but Congress revoked the commission's construction authority in 2013. The commission has not met since June 2013 and does not plan to meet until next month.

Daniel Fiel Frank Gehry
Eisenhower Memorial Commission (left); Creative Commons (right)

The commission has paid more than $11 million toward a $19 million contract with architect Frank Gehry (right) and $1.7 million to its own Executive Architect, Daniel Fiel (left).

Also last year, Bishop and six co-sponsors introduced an unsuccessful bill, the Dwight D. Eisenhower Memorial Completion Act, that would have limited terms on the commission and prohibited the use of federal funds for the project.

$19M Gehry Contract

The House report says that an accounting of the memorial costs is still incomplete, but it does note:

  • $11 million paid and $3.3 million in pending payments to Gehry and his firm for a design that does not meet legal requirements and design principles outlined in 2006. Including unexercised options, the Gehry contract totals $19 million;
  • Payments of more than $7.2 million to Gilbane Building Company, to manage construction and design;
  • Payments of almost $1.7 million to Executive Architect Daniel Feil for design management;
  • Millions of dollars spent to support the commission's politically connected nine-member staff and offices;
  • A jury evaluation that deemed the design entries "mediocre" and recommended an additional round of submissions—a recommendation the commission ignored; and
  • A design selection process that "substantially deviated from the standard Design Excellence Program" and was "weighted" to favor a well-known designer like Gehry.

"With millions spent," the panel concludes, "there is no memorial, and not even a memorial design that can be approved for construction."

   

Tagged categories: Architects; Construction; Design; Frank Gehry; Government contracts; Historic Structures; Monuments; Project Management

Comment from Tony Rangus, (9/2/2014, 4:54 PM)

Doesn't this sound like it needs some felony prosecutions?


Comment Join the Conversation:

Sign in to our community to add your comments.

Advertisements
 
SABRE Autonomous Solutions
 
Introducing the ALPHA1 Blasting Robot
 
Once installed and commissioned – simply
SCAN PLAN BLAST.
 

 
Safway Services
 
Your Access Advantage. QUIKDECK®
 
Provides safe, factory-floor-like working conditions. Can be engineered to fit almost any shape, structure or size. Modular platform easily assembled from just a few basic components. Excellent containment. Applications include vessels, offshore rigs and bridges.
 

 
Detail Masters
 
Overspray Removal
 
We offer professional, turnkey service and unparalleled quality!
Our process can save hundreds— even thousands of dollars. It's fast, environmentally safe and 100% guaranteed.
 

 
Strategic Materials Inc.
 
www.truabrasives.com
 
TruAbrasives™, a clean crushed glass abrasive superior to other abrasives for performance, health, and environmental benefits.
 

 
International WorkBoat Show
 
Power Forward
 
Join us Nov. 29 – Dec. 1 in New Orleans for the 2017 International WorkBoat Show. If it can power your business forward, you’ll find it here. Register Now!
 

 
Monti Tools, Inc.
 
BRISTLE BLASTER® – THE ORIGINAL ONE
 
  • Abrasive blast with a power tool
  • Remove corrosion, mill scale and coatings
  • Cleans & roughens
  • Meets SSPC-SP 10 / NACE No. 2
  • Profile up to 4.7 mils
  • ATEX Zone 1
  •  

     
    Tnemec Company, Inc.
     
    Online Coating Courses from Tnemec
     
    For decades, Tnemec has offered its expertise to clients presenting face-to-face coatings courses. Now, these presentations are available to anyone for CEUs at Tnemec University.
     

     
    Vector Technologies Ltd.
     
    The Original Performance Proven Vacuum Solutions
     
    VecLoader® 616 Double Dump, Continuous Vacuum, 170 HP w/ 2,400 CFM & 28” Hg. 33% More Efficient than traditional vacuum systems! Choose Vector for the most powerful and the most reliable trailer mounted vacuums in the industry! Email us at: inquiry@vector-vacuums.com or call us at: 800-832-4010
     

     
    PreTox Products - NexTec, Inc.
     
    GOT LEAD? Specify Pretox System products
     
    The ONLY Lead Stabilizer Compatible with All Paint Removal Methods. Works with all Blast Media: Grits | Recyclable Abrasives | CO2 | Water | Power Tools | Etc. Call Dave Steffen at 800.338.8296.
     

     
    SAFE Systems, Inc.
     
    Portable Blast &
    Recovery Equipment
     
    Trailer or skid mounted blast and recovery equipment. Systems designed for maximum versatility, environmental compliance
    and overall cost savings.
    Call 1-800-634-7278
     

     
     
     

    Technology Publishing Co., 1501 Reedsdale Street, Suite 2008, Pittsburgh, PA 15233

    TEL 1-412-431-8300  • FAX  1-412-431-5428  •  EMAIL webmaster@paintsquare.com


    The Technology Publishing Network

    Durability + Design PaintSquare the Journal of Protective Coatings & Linings Paint BidTracker

     
    EXPLORE:      JPCL   |   PaintSquare News   |   Interact   |   Buying Guides   |   Webinars   |   Resources   |   Classifieds
    REGISTER AND SUBSCRIBE:      Free PaintSquare Registration   |   Subscribe to JPCL   |   Subscribe to PaintSquare News
    MORE:      About PaintSquare.com   |   Privacy policy   |   Terms & conditions   |   Site Map   |   Search   |   Contact Us